Cornell University : Cornell Cooperative Extension


Yates Association
 

Shade Gardening in Western New York
By, Dot Hachten, CCE Livingston County

 

May 29, 2002

Undoubtedly one of the most difficult challenges for the home gardener is determining what to plant in the varying degrees of shade that may be encountered around the garden. While the choices among sun-loving plants is extensive those for shade are often limited and unexciting. With this article we hope to offer gardeners suggestions for dealing with their shady dilemma in the climatic conditions here in Yates County (Zone 5, with some limited microclimate areas of Zone 4 or Zone 6).

First, it is important to define what shade is exactly and describe the varying degrees to which it exists. We'll start with full sun as our reference point:

Full sun
is described as receiving at least 6 hours of direct sunlight per day.

Part shade is described as receiving at least 3 hours of direct sunlight per day.

Full shade is described as receiving less than 2 hours of direct sunlight per day. Within full shade there are further degrees of shading to be considered:

Dappled shade
may be a relatively bright area where, although it still receives minimal direct sunlight, may get some intermittently. These conditions often exist under trees, behind other foliage, or under a cover of lath or overhead lattice.

Open shade
is presented on the northern side of a structure, such as a building or wall, where there may be no direct sunlight but lots of light is present as reflected light off of the structure. This type of shade extends out as far as the shadow of the structure.

Medium shade
describes a condition where the area receives less than one hour per day of filtered sunlight or no sunlight at all; it is an area that could not be considered to be very bright.
Dense shade exists in areas where very dense tree canopies, tall walls, and buildings or combinations of these obscure all direct sunlight from ever reaching the ground; there is minimal reflected light.

Prior to planting your shade site you must evaluate your proj ect as you would before gardening in any site.


1. What is the soil type and pH and will you need to amend the soil to achieve your goals?

2. Are there objects or geographical features which will store or reflect heat and warm the area; sometimes this excessive heat production will take its toll on plants that prefer cool spots. These features can sometimes create a microclimate ilia limited area. Will these features limit growth of roots?

3. How much sun is present at different times of the year? Are there excessive winds? Is there enough air circulation to prevent fungal diseases? Are there any plants nearby that release toxins through their roots systems (such as black walnuts) that would stunt or kill off non-compatible plants?

4. Is the site plagued with excessive water or dryness? If you need to drain wet sites do you have a plan? If you need to irrigate, do you have a handy water source, and what will be the financial cost of doing so?

5. How much time and money are you willing to commit to the project, not just at the outset but also during the maintenance of the area?

6. How will the area be used? Will there be pedestrian traffic, pets, or wildlife? Is it to be a high-maintenance, formal planting or perhaps will it be left to naturalize with little or no mowing?

7. What sorts of problems will you need to attend to before beginning your project, such as checking for the location of underground wires, pipes, etc. Making a list is a good idea.

8. Do you really want plant material or would non-living materials be a better choice? (i.e. stone, gravel, bricks, pavers, mulch, etc.)

Planning a shade garden requires a few other considerations:

1. If your site receives some sun is it in the afternoon? Many shade-loving plants like cool conditions and cannot tolerate the strong afternoon sun.

2. Are there structures or features that reflect or trap heat? Again, cooler conditions are generally preferred.

3. If large trees are shading the area will they compete with the planting for water? Will their roots make it too difficult to dig and prepare the soil?

4. Is it an option to modify the shade area, such as by pruning to decrease the density of the shade?
When you have compiled your answers to these considerations you are then in the position to make some educated decisions what to plant. But where do you start?

Develop your vision: Visit garden centers and nurseries; go on a garden tour or visit public gardens and arboretums. Arm yourself with as much knowledge as you can to create your vision.

Make your selections: Look in catalogs and books for a broad idea of what is available for your growing conditions or consult with Cornell Cooperative Extension; talk to knowledgeable nurserymen and horticultural growers to see what is available in this area. In making your selection be sure to consider the ultimate size of the plant at maturity so that it is neither too big for the space or is too small to have the impact you hope for.

After you have decided on what plants that you are going to work with make a detailed plan for the site and prepare the soil. Then purchase your plants according to the conditions present at your site; remember that if planted in less than ideal situations a specimen may live for a year or two but over time they will either fail to thrive or even die. Select healthy specimens grown in conditions similar to where they will end up (a specimen grown in a southern state may have a more difficult and longer time of acclimation than one grown in a similar Zone).

What follows is a short list of plants that are compatible with shade areas in Zone 5. This is not an all-inclusive list but is intended to give you a place to start in developing your goals. Again, before selecting a plant species be sure that it's requirements are compatible with conditions on your site. A more comprehensive and detailed list is available from Cornell Cooperative Extension, or check with local nurseries.

Plants compatible with shade areas in Zone 5


Perennials: astilbe, hosta, lily of the valley, primula, decentra, ferns

Vines: bittersweet, wintercreeper, English ivy, Boston ivy, Virginia creeper, climbing hydrangea

Ground covers
: pachysandra, vinca, sweet woodruff, wild ginger, creeping cotoneaster, bunchberry

Shrubs
: snowberry, yew, arborvitae, viburnum, bog rosemary, common bearberry, scotch heather cultivars, Oregon grape holly, bayberry

Trees: Shadbush, Japanese maple, bottlebrush buckeye, Eruopean filbert (Harry Lauder walking stick), dogwoods



Cornell Cooperative Extension Yates Association
Last updated: 5/21/02

top